Fire your SEO agency when it can't show you a list of the work done each month, won't put your Google accounts in your name, or has made changes to your site it can't explain. Slow results on their own aren't always a reason, because SEO takes months. FIELDINGS Marketing runs its SEO retainer month to month because the same rule should apply to us: if the work isn't delivering, you should be free to leave.
The hard part is telling a slow start from a bad provider. This guide helps you sort one from the other, then leave cleanly if it comes to that.
The Short Version
- Give a new agency a few months, but expect a clear work list from the first month.
- Leave if they guarantee rankings, hide what they're doing or own your accounts.
- Before you leave, get owner access to Search Console, Analytics and your Business Profile.
- Get a list of every change they made, every page they wrote and every link they built.
- Don't delete pages they created that bring in traffic.
Disappointed In A New SEO Agency? Should You Fire Them?
Maybe not yet. Start by separating two different problems: results that are slow, and work you can't see.
Slow results can be normal. Google's own guide says some changes take effect within hours and others take several months, and suggests waiting a few weeks before judging whether a change worked (SEO Starter Guide, updated December 2025). The first month with a new agency often goes on audits, fixes and setup. Our guide to how long SEO takes sets out what a normal timeline looks like.
Work you can't see is a different matter. Even in the first month, you should be able to get answers to three questions:
- What did you find when you reviewed my site?
- What did you change, and on which pages?
- What's the plan for next month, and why?
If the agency can answer those clearly, give it time. If it can't, the disappointment is telling you something, and it's probably not about rankings.
Signs It's Time To Fire Your SEO Agency
There's No List Of Work
You should know what was done each month: pages written or improved, technical issues fixed, Business Profile posts published. A report that's only a ranking chart, or forty pages of exported data, hides more than it shows.
They Guaranteed Rankings
Google's guidance on hiring an SEO is blunt: "No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google" (Google Search Central, updated June 2026). If that promise is what sold you, the rest of the pitch deserves a second look.
They Won't Explain What They're Doing
Google also warns: "Be careful if a company is secretive or won't clearly explain what they intend to do." It adds that you're responsible for the actions of any company you hire. If an agency won't tell you what it changed on your site, you can't check whether it helped or hurt.
Your Accounts Are In Their Name
Search Console, Google Analytics and your Google Business Profile should belong to you, with the agency added as a user. If the agency owns them, you lose your data and history when you leave.
The Links Look Wrong
Google says to avoid SEOs that talk about "link popularity schemes" and that "you should never have to link to an SEO." If your reports list hundreds of links from sites unrelated to your business, or your site now links to the agency in ways you didn't agree to, ask what they are.
Traffic Dropped And Nobody Can Say Why
Rankings move around. But if Search Console shows a sharp, lasting drop after the agency made changes, and the agency can't explain it, that's a problem. Common causes are pages set to noindex by mistake, broken redirects and content that was cut back.
You Can't Reach The Person Doing The Work
Every question goes through an account manager, and answers take days. Our guide to onshore and offshore SEO providers covers why that gap matters and how to spot it before you sign.
Signs To Give It A Little Longer
- You get a specific list of work every month.
- New pages show as indexed in Search Console.
- Impressions are rising for the services you care about, even if clicks are still low.
- The agency explains its changes and answers questions within a day or two.
- Your market is crowded, or your site is new.
If most of those are true, the work is probably landing. Results tend to follow impressions. If the real question is whether SEO is worth paying for at all, our guide to whether SEO is worth it helps you work that out.
How To Leave Without Losing Ground
If you've decided to go, do it in this order.
- Read the contract. Check the notice period and who owns the content, links and accounts the agency created.
- Get owner access to your accounts. Search Console, Google Analytics, Google Business Profile and Google Ads if you run it. Make sure you're the owner, not just a user.
- Ask for a list of every change. Pages written, pages edited, redirects added, technical settings changed. Google's guidance says an SEO with access to your server should be willing to explain all the changes it makes.
- Export your Search Console data. Google keeps 16 months of performance data. Export it now so you have a baseline.
- Get the list of links and listings. Directories, citations and any links the agency built, with logins where they exist.
- Leave the good pages alone. Content that brings in traffic should stay, even if you plan to rewrite it later. If addresses change, redirect each old page to its closest new one. Our website redesign guide covers redirects in detail.
- Remove access last. Once you have everything, remove the agency's access and change any shared passwords.
What To Ask The Next Provider
Google suggests asking any SEO for examples of previous work, whether it follows Google's Search Essentials, what results to expect and in what timeframe, and how it will share the changes it makes. It also suggests giving a new SEO read-only access to Search Console while it audits, rather than write access.
Add a few of your own:
- Who will do the work on my account, by name?
- Can I talk to that person directly?
- Can I see a sample monthly work list from a current client, with the name removed?
- What's the notice period if it isn't working?
How FIELDINGS Marketing Works
FIELDINGS Marketing is a Perth business run by Sam Fielding. Sam handles the strategy and the work, and he's the person you speak with from the first call. You can read more about Sam.
The monthly SEO retainer runs month to month with no lock-in contract. It starts with a review of the site you already have. Each monthly report covers the work completed, what changed and where the focus goes next, so you can judge it every month. If it isn't working, you can leave.
Frequently Asked Questions
How Long Should I Give A New SEO Agency?
Long enough to see a trend, which usually means a few months. But expect a clear work list from the first month. Time is fair to ask for. Silence isn't.
Can I Fire My SEO Agency Mid-Contract?
Check the contract's notice period and exit terms first. Some contracts run for a fixed term with a fee to leave early. FIELDINGS Marketing runs month to month, so there's no lock-in to wait out.
Will My Rankings Drop If I Change SEO Agency?
Not if your pages stay up and nothing is removed. The risk comes when an agency takes down content it wrote, removes links it controls or leaves settings broken. Get the full list of changes and keep the pages that bring in traffic.
Who Owns The Content My SEO Agency Wrote?
It depends on your contract. Check it before you give notice, and ask the agency to confirm in writing that the content on your site stays with you.
Should I Tell My Agency Why I'm Leaving?
It's up to you. Either way, ask for a proper handover: account access, a list of changes and a list of links. A good agency will provide it without a fuss.
The Outcome You Should Expect
Whoever does your SEO, you should finish each month knowing what was done, who did it and what it changed. If your agency can't tell you that, it's time to find one that can, and to take your accounts, data and content with you when you go.
